Kimberli's Kitchen
Friday November 24th 2017

Kitchen Sink Cookies

There are times when I need a break from chocolate chip cookies. Call me crazy, OK, I’m crazy. As I’ve been looking out in cookieland this week during National Cookie Week I’ve seen a lot of great chocolate options, but I’ve decided to provide yet another no-chocolate cookie. It is chock full of tasty bits though, so I’m not sure you’ll miss the chocolate!!

Kitchen Sink Cookies

So far, this has won the YUMMY AWARD of the WEEK around The MacKay Way. They are that good!

Bake up a batch, turn on the milk tap and dive in… we did!


Kitchen Sink Cookies

Makes 5-6 dozen (which you’ll find to not NEARLY be enough. Perhaps pencil into your calendar now to make them up again early next week.)

2 eggs + 1 egg yolk (reserve the white for that omelette you’ve been craving all day!)
1 cup (2 sticks) butter, softened
3/4 cup granulated white sugar
1/2 cup brown sugar, packed
2 1/2 cups of oatmeal
1.5 cups of unsweetened grated coconut*
1 bag, 11-12 oz. of butterscotch chips (I’ve seen bags in both sizes
2/3 cup shelled pumpkin seeds (I like the small sort you find in India markets called Char Magaz)
1 1/2 cups of toasted and candied pecans (see below for instructions
1/2 teaspoon of salt
1/2 teaspoon of baking powder
1/2 teaspoon of baking soda
1 1/2 cups of all-purpose flour
1 teaspoon vanilla extract

Toasted & Candied Pecans:
1 1/2 Cups of pecans as listed above, chopped
1/4 cup of dark brown sugar
large dinner plate

Preheat oven 375F°.

Candied Pecans

Toasting & Candying Nuts:
Break the nuts into a few pieces by hand or with a large knife. When candying them, I prefer to break them by hand and have less “nut dust”. Have all items at the ready, including the dinner plate and stirring spoon when you begin this part. Put the nuts into a small, dry, frying pan over medium high heat and cook until they begin to toast. Be sure to stir the nuts as you cook. BEWARE: Nuts will go from toasted to burned quite quickly. When they begin to toast, lower the heat to medium and dump on the brown sugar and mix quickly. When I say quickly – I mean it will burn super fast so stir like hell and pour the contents out onto a plate immediately to begin cooling. DO NOT touch any nuts that spill onto the counter or that remain in the pan. You WILL get one heck of a sugar burn, and sugar burns suck. Let the nuts cool and break them up once cooled.

Let’s get on with it, shall we?
Mix the flour, baking soda, baking powder and salt. Set aside for now.

In a mixer, cream the butter. Add the sugars and mix well. Add the eggs (including the additional 3rd yolk) and vanilla and mix on medium speed until the batter is fluffy. Add the flour a little at a time until all is well blended.

Kitchen towel flour saverTIP: When I add the flour to the mixer, even though I have a splatter shield, I place a towel over the mixer to help keep the flour from invading the entire kitchen.

After the flour is mixed in, add the coconut followed by the oatmeal, mixing between additions. Finally, add the butterscotch chips,  pumpkin seeds and candied pecans and give it a quick mix.

Oven ready.

Place by tablespoon full, flattening slightly with damp fingers, onto ungreased cookie sheets.  They do not spread very much. Bake for 9-12 minutes, until the bottoms begin to brown around the edges. Allow to cool enough on a wire rack that you don’t burn your tongue snarfing one down.

Kitchen Sink Cookies... they won't last long!

* Unsweetened shredded coconut can be found in the freezer section of your local Indian market.

Art by: ©2011

Kitchen Sink Cookie on Foodistavisit Link

2 Comments for “Kitchen Sink Cookies”

  • Christine's Pantry says:

    I love the name you gave the cookies. Also like the photos. Congrats on winning award.

  • Kim's Mom, Judie says:

    A friend was here and could not get enough of these cookies. You gave him the recipe and he made 3 copies of it in case they lost one!!

Leave a Comment

More from category

Bavarian Apple Torte
Bavarian Apple Torte

Over the summer the aunt of a dear friend passed away. We had enjoyed delicious meals at Aunt Mary’s house and [Read More]

Look What Arrived in the Mail Today!
Look What Arrived in the Mail Today!

A few months ago I popped my email address into a sweepstakes being run on the Bridesmaids Movie Official website. I [Read More]

Gingerific Snap Cookies
Gingerific Snap Cookies

I love ginger. This cookie is so terrifically filled with ginger that I had to call it Gingerific! The baking of these [Read More]

I won, I won!!
I won, I won!!

Congratulations to Becky over at Baking and Cooking: A Tale of Two Loves. Her online bake sale raised $590 for The [Read More]



Latest Topics

Bavarian Apple Torte

Over the summer the aunt of a dear friend passed away. We had enjoyed delicious meals at Aunt Mary’s house and [Read More]

Spicy Shrimp Tacos

There are days when I come home having taught a 12 hour day and the thought of cooking is almost too much for me. [Read More]

Preserved Lemons, a Lovely Gift!

As with the rest of the country, finances have been tightened up here at The MacKay Way. With the holidays rolling [Read More]

Thanksgiving Planning 101

I love Thanksgiving. It’s a time for me to pull out all of the stops and show my friends and family how much I [Read More]

Grilled Salad (You read that right!)

Looking for a healthy option for your next tail gate? What could be better than a vegetarian dish that is tasty, easy [Read More]